Looking at the case studies this week showing how libraries use the social tagging site 'Del.icio.us' reminded me of the old 'Vertical File' system I used to maintain working in a public and school library. These were documents that I would save under a specific label which might be useful for someone researching this topic of for a school project for example. The difference here is that I would be the only person doing this and presumably in the libraries in the case studies there are many people choosing articles from the Internet and 'saving' them in a file under their library name in Del.icio.us. Why are the saving them?? I was looking at the tag cloud in the LaGrange Park Library and wondering why anyone would tag a website showing a list of free knitting patterns. I have nothing against knitting, but what does this have to do with the library? There is a tag called 'cicadas' which takes the user to a very nice site on cicadas in Illinois, but where is the relevance to the library?
I have looked at Maui Community College library and wondered why there would be tagged a site on the Big Business of Dairy farming? It is even listed on the library homepage. Its an interesting informative site, but what is its relevance with Maui Community College Library?
The Penn Tags site opens with a tag cloud of popular tags and then lists pages and pages of boring information that would take hours to unravel and work out what the content is. I am really not sure what all this is about.
The Seldovia library at Del.icio.us is more of what I would expect for a library to tag and there appears to be many tags related to library information. Once again it looks like a vertical file with the library related tags in a darked and larger font making them more visible. It would be nice to be able to link the title of the library on the top of the page to the library website. I would like to use that to find out where the library was located.
The Thomas Ford Memorial Library has only 65 tags in the tag cloud which is a small number considering that they have been tagging for at least two years. Once again I am not sure why tags for 'recipes' and 'food' are listed here.
It seems by looking at these tags for libraries that anything can be tagged and there are no rules or guidelines to decide what can or cannot be included in a library's bookmarking site.
The number of tags at Lansing Public Library is enormous and once again looks like the old 'vertical file'. If the purpose for the long alphabetical list of subjects under the auspices of the library is to provide an access point for students or any researchers to find information on anything listed, then this is surely not the way to do research. I looked under the 'Dickens' tag and found only one site, 'Birds' had 4 sites, 'Ecology' had 4 and 'Soccer' had 4. Based on this it would be more efficient and effective to search 'Google' to find any required information.
Michael Jenson in his article on 'The New Metrics of Scholarly Authority' in the Chronicle Review described Del.icio.us as 'a collection of favourite sites where descriptive tags denoting contents raise the authority of the listed site'
If this is the purpose of tagging a site especially under the auspices of a library, then there needs to be some guidelines established as to the authority, content and future use of the website.
In my opinion, just because someone tags it for personal future use be it in a library or not, does not immediately raise the authority of the site.
Showing posts with label tags. Show all posts
Showing posts with label tags. Show all posts
Thursday, June 21, 2007
Monday, June 18, 2007
Libraries turning into bookstores and Tagging at 'Lavalife'!!
The idea behind social bookmarking or tagging is that the person who will retrieve the information at a later date is the one who decides which tags to use. 'Folksonomy' is the general public or folk choosing their own keywords to tag the items they want to remember or return to at a later date. The same idea is behind wikis previously discussed whereby folks who have no previous experience with web design or html can contribute to a website and feel that their opinion and input are as important as those web designers who have extensive technological knowledge. The idea of wikis, social bookmarking and blog creation is opening up many doors for the 'common man' to contribute in many ways with his ideas, knowledge and creativity.
Tony Hammond talks about 'phonetags' whereby listeners hear a song and use a cell phone to tag it to a website and retrieve it later and see the bookmarked songs. The same system could be used for retrieving information about books, titles or authors that someone was looking at in a bookstore or library which they wanted to remember. The site 'Del.icio.us' as a social bookmarking manager could also be used to remember a list of titles or authors as is shown by two of themore popular tags such as 'toread' and a 'wishlist'.
Adam Mathes in his article entitles 'Folksonomies' makes an interesting point when he talks about people's behaviour being influenced by other users of the same social bookmarking site and developing relationships with groups of users who share tag use. If the retrieval systems incorporate user centered managment tools, these schemes developed by users have the potential to be popular and well used. As a translation if 'Joe Public' tagged the books in a library it would be used and understood and be more accessible by more people. In my opinion it would probably result in a real mess! Is it just a matter of time before tagging extends to the 'real world away from the technological one and libraries consider a complete different organisation of resources.? The Gilbert Library in Arizona is the first library in the USA to reorganise its books based on a book store model. However I am not sure how inter library loans between branches would work if one library developed its own system. But I am sure there will be ways around this.
Joshua Porter talks about not being blinded by the aggregation light and emphasises the fact that people do not tag for the sake of tagging. The articles must have value to the tagger before he or she will tag and and he stresses that software developers must ensure that they produce something that people will value and want to tag. The opportunity to tag will be beneficial to those people who are already engaged in certain activities on the Internet and tagging will be the 'cream on the cake'.
In the many dating sites on the Internet the opportunities are enormous to tag 'people' that look interesting and build a 'possibilities' list for future reference. Such tags as 'musical', 'hockey dad' or 'sports jock' might be seen on a 'del.icio.us/lavalife' site !! The opportunities are endless!!
Tony Hammond talks about 'phonetags' whereby listeners hear a song and use a cell phone to tag it to a website and retrieve it later and see the bookmarked songs. The same system could be used for retrieving information about books, titles or authors that someone was looking at in a bookstore or library which they wanted to remember. The site 'Del.icio.us' as a social bookmarking manager could also be used to remember a list of titles or authors as is shown by two of themore popular tags such as 'toread' and a 'wishlist'.
Adam Mathes in his article entitles 'Folksonomies' makes an interesting point when he talks about people's behaviour being influenced by other users of the same social bookmarking site and developing relationships with groups of users who share tag use. If the retrieval systems incorporate user centered managment tools, these schemes developed by users have the potential to be popular and well used. As a translation if 'Joe Public' tagged the books in a library it would be used and understood and be more accessible by more people. In my opinion it would probably result in a real mess! Is it just a matter of time before tagging extends to the 'real world away from the technological one and libraries consider a complete different organisation of resources.? The Gilbert Library in Arizona is the first library in the USA to reorganise its books based on a book store model. However I am not sure how inter library loans between branches would work if one library developed its own system. But I am sure there will be ways around this.
Joshua Porter talks about not being blinded by the aggregation light and emphasises the fact that people do not tag for the sake of tagging. The articles must have value to the tagger before he or she will tag and and he stresses that software developers must ensure that they produce something that people will value and want to tag. The opportunity to tag will be beneficial to those people who are already engaged in certain activities on the Internet and tagging will be the 'cream on the cake'.
In the many dating sites on the Internet the opportunities are enormous to tag 'people' that look interesting and build a 'possibilities' list for future reference. Such tags as 'musical', 'hockey dad' or 'sports jock' might be seen on a 'del.icio.us/lavalife' site !! The opportunities are endless!!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
